This article is part of a series of 50 policy reviews. Professional Indemnity Insurance (PI) which specifically covers important clauses in the policy so that professionals better understand the protection they have. In this edition, we will discuss subrogation, a legal term that is often confusing, but is actually very decisive in the management of insurance claims.
Subrogation is the right of an insurance company to take the insured’s place in suing a third party after a claim has been paid. This clause is important because it not only protects the insurance company from multiple losses but also ensures the insured is not harmed twice in a single case. However, without proper understanding, subrogation can lead to misunderstandings or even disputes.
This article was written by Mhd. Taufik Arifin ANZIIF (snr.assoc) CIIB, an insurance broker with over 40 years of experience, who has assisted numerous companies in the legal, construction, medical, financial, and IT sectors. Working with L&G Insurance Broker, this article provides not only education but also practical guidance on how to address subrogation issues to ensure truly effective IP protection.
Definition of Subrogation
In the insurance world, including Professional Indemnity (PI) insurance, the term subrogation refers to the insurance company’s right to take over the insured’s legal position after a claim has been paid. This means that if the insurance company has compensated you as a professional, they have the right to sue any third party deemed responsible for those losses.
Legally, this concept is regulated in Article 284 of the Indonesian Commercial Code (KUHD), which states that upon payment of a claim, the insured’s rights automatically transfer to the insurer (insurance company). This allows the insurance company to collect damages from any third party responsible for the loss, whether an individual or a legal entity.
In the context of IP policies, subrogation often occurs in lawsuits involving more than one party. For example, an architect might be sued for a design error, but the error also involved the contractor. If the claim is paid by the architect’s insurance company, the insurance company can subrogate the claim to the contractor to recover part of the loss.
It’s important to note that subrogation doesn’t diminish the insured’s right to compensation. Instead, it prevents the insured from having to pay twice for losses or get caught up in multiple lawsuits. However, subrogation also limits the insured’s actions—for example, you shouldn’t sign an agreement with a third party that waives the insurance company’s right to subrogation, as this could lead to a claim being denied.
This is why understanding subrogation is so important. With the guidance of an experienced insurance broker such as L&G Insurance Broker, you can ensure that the subrogation clause is understood correctly so that it does not cause legal problems later on.
Functions of Subrogation in PI Insurance
Subrogation plays a crucial role in Professional Indemnity (PI) insurance practices. This mechanism is not merely a legal formality, but rather a strategic instrument for maintaining a balance between the interests of the insured, the insurer, and third parties.
First, it protects the insured’s interests. Once a claim is paid, the insured is no longer burdened with financial risk. Subrogation allows the insurance company to pursue third-party liability, saving the insured the hassle of additional legal proceedings.
Second, maintaining justice between the parties. Without subrogation, there is a risk that the guilty third party escapes without consequence. With the right of subrogation, the insurance company can claim them to bear the loss. This ensures that the burden is not only borne by one party.
Third, improving the sustainability of the insurance system. Subrogation allows insurance companies to recover a portion of the claims funds they have paid. These recovered funds help maintain the financial stability of the insurance system, ultimately providing long-term benefits to all policyholders.
In IP practice, the function of subrogation is particularly relevant when claims involve multiple professional parties. For example, in a construction project, a consultant might be sued by a client, even though the fault also involved the contractor or subcontractor. If the claim is covered by the consultant’s insurance, the insurance company can sue the contractor through subrogation, thus more equitably distributing liability.
To ensure effective subrogation, it’s crucial for the insured to understand the policy’s clauses. An insurance broker like L&G Insurance Broker can help explain the legal implications and appropriate strategies, ensuring the insured remains protected without violating the insurance company’s subrogation rights.
Legal Basis of Subrogation in Indonesia and Internationally
Subrogation in insurance, including Professional Indemnity (PI), has a strong legal basis both in Indonesia and internationally. This principle ensures that the insurer who has paid the claim has the right to take the insured’s place in suing the guilty third party.
- Legal Basis in Indonesia
In Indonesia, subrogation is clearly regulated in Articles 284, 1400, and 1401 of the Civil Code (KUHPerdata), and is reaffirmed in Article 284 of the Commercial Code (KUHD), which specifically addresses subrogation in insurance. Essentially, once a claim is paid, the insurance company automatically has the right to take the insured’s place and demand compensation from a third party.
An example of its application in Indonesia is in the case of transportation insurance and construction projects, where the initial claim is paid to the policyholder, then the insurer sues the contractor or subcontractor who is proven to be negligent.
- International Legal Basis
Globally, the principle of subrogation is also widely recognized. In common law systems such as the United Kingdom, the United States, and Singapore, subrogation stems from the principle of equity, which aims to prevent the insured from receiving double recovery. Meanwhile, in civil law systems such as those in Europe, subrogation is institutionalized in each country’s civil code.
For example, in the UK, subrogation developed through court decisions (case law), while in the European Union it is regulated by the European Insurance Contract Law, which harmonizes subrogation practices across countries. In the United States, the principle of subrogation is reinforced by various state laws and jurisprudence that consistently support insurers’ rights after claims payment.
- Relevance in PI Insurance
In the context of IP, this legal basis provides certainty for all parties. Protected professionals are not disadvantaged, insurance companies have a strong basis for suing third parties, and the legal system ensures a fair distribution of liability.
In Indonesia, a thorough understanding of local regulations and global practices is crucial. Therefore, L&G Insurance Broker acts as a strategic partner to help clients understand, draft, and negotiate subrogation clauses in accordance with international standards without violating national regulations.
Types of Subrogation in PI Insurance
Subrogation in insurance, including Professional Indemnity (PI), is not a single form, but has several variations that have developed in legal practice and insurance contracts. Understanding these types of subrogation is important for professionals and companies to avoid missteps when facing lawsuits or third-party claims.
- Legal Subrogation (By Operation of Law)
This type arises automatically under the law. In Indonesia, this is affirmed in the Civil Code and Commercial Code. Once an insurance company pays a claim to the insured, the insurer automatically has the right to take the insured’s place in suing any third party deemed responsible for the loss.
Example: An architect faces a lawsuit from a client due to a material error actually made by the contractor. After the PI claim is paid, the insurance company can sue the contractor to recover a portion of the claim payment.
- Conventional Subrogation (By Agreement)
This type of subrogation arises from an agreement between the insured and the insurer. This agreement can be outlined in the insurance policy or in an additional document (endorsement). Conventional subrogation typically details the transfer mechanism, limitations, and distribution of recovery proceeds, if any.
Example: In the international PI policy, there is a clause that requires the insured to fully cooperate with the insurer in the subrogation process, including preparing documents or being a witness in court.
- Subrogasi Equitable (Equitable Subrogation)
This type is particularly applicable in common law jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom, the United States, and Singapore. Equitable subrogation arises from the principle of equity, which prevents the insured from receiving double recovery. In other words, even if it’s not expressly stated in the contract, a court can establish the existence of a right of subrogation to maintain fairness.
Example: A legal consultant receives full compensation from PI insurance and also receives compensation from a third party. The court may decide that one of the compensations should be transferred to the insurer.
- Partial Subrogation
In some cases, the insurer only pays a portion of the loss due to a deductible or limit of liability. Therefore, subrogation rights can be shared between the insurer and the insured.
Example: A PI claim is IDR 10 billion, while the policy limit is IDR 7 billion. The insurer has the right to subrogate the IDR 7 billion, while the insured still has the right to IDR 3 billion.
By understanding the different types of subrogation, professionals can be better prepared to develop risk protection strategies. L&G Insurance Broker consistently emphasizes the importance of clear subrogation clauses in IP policies to ensure the insured’s rights are protected while maximizing potential claim recovery.
The Subrogation Process in Practice
Subrogation in Professional Indemnity (PI) insurance isn’t just a legal theory; it involves a systematic process. This process is crucial for both the insurance company and the insured to recover the funds paid as claims.
- Claim Payment
The subrogation process always begins with the insurance company’s payment of the claim to the insured. Without payment of the claim, the right of subrogation does not arise. After payment, the insurer automatically (or as agreed) has the right to replace the insured.
- Third Party Investigation and Identification
Once a claim is paid, the next step is an investigation to determine whether any third parties are liable. For example, in the case of a construction project, a claim may arise from a material supplier’s error, rather than purely the architect’s negligence.
- Collection of Evidence and Documents
The insurer, along with the broker, will gather relevant documents such as contracts, technical reports, meeting minutes, and correspondence. At this stage, the involvement of an insurance broker like L&G Insurance Broker is crucial, as brokers are accustomed to assisting clients in preparing comprehensive documentation to strengthen their claims position.
- Negotiation with Third Parties
Not all subrogations end up in court. Often, the initial approach involves negotiation or mediation with a third party. The goal is to reach an agreement on compensation without having to go through a lengthy and expensive legal process.
- Litigation in Court
If negotiations fail, the insurer will then proceed to legal action. At this stage, the insured remains obligated to cooperate with the insurer, for example by acting as a witness or providing additional data.
- Distribution of Subrogation Results
If the insurer successfully obtains reimbursement from a third party, the proceeds will be used to cover claims already paid. If there is a surplus (for example, because the insured’s claim was not fully paid due to a limit), the remainder can be transferred back to the insured.
With this structured process, subrogation not only protects the interests of the insurer, but also safeguards justice for the insured. However, the success of subrogation is highly dependent on understanding the details of contracts, regulations, and legal practices in the field.
That’s why working with an experienced insurance broker like L&G Insurance Broker is so important. Brokers ensure that subrogation clauses are clearly defined from the outset, so that when a claim arises, the subrogation process can proceed smoothly and yield optimal results for all parties.
Challenges in PI Insurance Subrogation
Although subrogation is a legitimate right of insurance companies, in practice, this process often faces various challenges. One major obstacle is the complexity of proving liability. Proving a third party is truly liable requires documentary evidence, witnesses, and technical analysis, which are not always easy to obtain.
Furthermore, litigation costs are often prohibitive. Legal proceedings are time-consuming and costly, while the outcome is not always certain. Furthermore, in many cases, third parties may not have sufficient financial capacity to pay damages, so even if a lawsuit is won, recovery remains limited.
Another challenge is differences in legal jurisdictions, especially in cross-border cases. Subrogation regulations in Europe, the United States, and Asia differ significantly, requiring insurance companies and insured parties to adapt their legal strategies to local conditions.
To address these challenges, experienced insurance brokers like L&G Insurance Broker play a crucial role. Brokers help insured parties understand risks from the outset, draft clear subrogation clauses, and guide them through the claims process to settlement, ensuring optimal protection.
Subrogation Benefits for Insured and Insurer
The subrogation clause in Professional Indemnity (PI) insurance provides major benefits, both for the insurance company (insurer) and the insured party.
- Benefits for the Insurer
For insurance companies, subrogation is a mechanism to mitigate financial losses. After paying a claim to the insured, the insurer has the right to sue the responsible third party. This way, the insurance company doesn’t have to bear the entire burden of the loss alone. This also maintains the insurance company’s financial health, allowing them to continue providing coverage to many other customers.
- Benefits for the Insured
For the insured, subrogation provides guaranteed protection. Once a claim is approved and paid, the financial burden is immediately reduced. Legal liability or losses incurred can be immediately covered, while the insurance company takes over subsequent legal action against the third party. This way, the insured avoids incurring additional costs or facing complex legal proceedings.
Furthermore, subrogation can also prevent double recovery, a situation where the insured receives double compensation from both a third party and the insurer. This maintains fairness, ensuring a balanced legal relationship between the insured, the insurer, and the third party.
This is where the role of an insurance broker like L&G Insurance Broker is key. Brokers ensure that subrogation clauses are clearly drafted, ensuring that the insured’s benefits are not diminished. With over 40 years of experience, L&G is able to ensure each client receives maximum protection from their PI policy.
Case Study of Subrogation in PI Insurance
To understand how subrogation works in practice, let’s look at some real-life case studies in the professional world that are relevant to Professional Indemnity (PI) policies.
- Case of Architect and Material Supplier
An architectural firm in Jakarta faced a lawsuit from a client after a building design developed a large crack after the project was completed. The PI policy covered the claim, which totaled Rp 8 billion. An investigation revealed that some of the damage stemmed from low-quality concrete supplied by a third party. The insurance company, which had already paid the claim, exercised its subrogation rights to sue the material supplier. As a result, some of the losses were recovered, eliminating the architect’s liability.
- Case of IT Consultants and Software Vendors
An IT consultant was sued by a large company because the system he designed failed to prevent a data leak. The claim reached Rp 12 billion, covered by the PI policy. An investigation revealed the leak originated from a security flaw in third-party software used on the project. The insurance company exercised its subrogation rights to sue the software vendor, and partially recovered the damages.
- Case of Auditor and Client Management
An audit firm in Surabaya was accused of negligence for failing to detect fraud in financial reports. The claim amounted to Rp 20 billion. After the claim was paid, the insurance company conducted an investigation and discovered that the client’s management had intentionally concealed material information. Through subrogation, the insurer sued the company’s management and successfully recovered some of the funds.
The three cases above demonstrate that subrogation not only protects the insurer’s interests but also safeguards the insured’s reputation and financial stability. However, without a properly drafted IP policy and a clear subrogation clause, this process can be hampered.
Experienced insurance brokers like L&G Insurance Broker play a crucial role in designing policies that meet international standards while also being relevant to local conditions. With over 40 years of experience, L&G ensures that clients are protected not only during claims but also during subrogation proceedings.
Conclusion and Recommendations
Subrogation is a crucial element of a Professional Indemnity (PI) insurance policy. This clause gives the insurance company the right to take the insured’s place in suing a third party after the claim has been paid. The goal is clear: to maintain the insurer’s financial balance while protecting the insured from double burdens. In many cases, subrogation has proven effective in partially recovering losses and ensuring that the truly responsible party shares the legal consequences.
However, the practice of subrogation is not always straightforward. Challenges such as litigation costs, differences in jurisdictions, and the financial capabilities of third parties often present obstacles. Therefore, a thorough understanding of the subrogation clause from the outset is crucial to avoid misperceptions. The insured needs to understand that the subrogation process is for the common good, not solely for the insurance company’s benefit.
This is where the role of an experienced insurance broker becomes crucial. Brokers like L&G Insurance Broker can help negotiate the terms of an IP policy, ensure clear subrogation clauses, and assist clients throughout the claims and subrogation process. With over 40 years of experience across various industries, L&G has proven itself a trusted partner for companies in legal, medical, construction, IT, and financial sectors.
Recommendation: If you’re a professional or service-based business owner, never underestimate the subrogation clause in your IP policy. Ensure your policy is properly drafted with a trusted broker like L&G to ensure you receive maximum protection and keep your business safe from the risk of lawsuits.
—
DON’T WASTE YOUR TIME AND SECURE YOUR MINING FINANCIAL AND BUSINESS WITH THE RIGHT INSURANCE.
HOTLINE L&G 24 JAM: 0811-8507-773 (CALL – WHATSAPP – SMS)
Website: lngrisk.co.id
Email: halo@lngrisk.co.id
—
