Liga Asuransi – Project owners, contractors and subcontractors, how are you? May you, your family and your business always run smoothly. In this blog, we focus on discussing risk management and project insurance, incl Construction All Risk (CAR), Erection All Risk (EAR), Third-Party Liability Insurance, Performance Bond, and Surety Bond. If this article is useful, please share it with your colleagues. Also get hundreds of other articles about construction insurance and contractor protection only on this blog!
The construction industry is a sector with a high level of risk. Construction projects face various challenges, such as physical damage, project delays, work accidents, and third party claims due to the impact of construction activities. Without adequate protection, contractors and project owners could experience significant financial losses, which could potentially hinder project progress or even lead to bankruptcy.
Therefore, project insurance is a primary requirement for all parties involved in construction. Construction All Risk (CAR) and Erection All Risk (EAR) provide protection against physical project risks, temporarily Third-Party Liability Insurance cover claims from affected third parties. In addition, Professional Indemnity Insurance protects against planning or design errors, and the Performance Bond and Surety Bond guarantee the contractor’s commitment to completing the project according to the contract.
This article aims to provide an understanding of the types of construction insurance that must be owned. By having the right protections in place, contractors and project owners can better manage risks, maintain investment sustainability, and ensure project operations run without obstacles.
In the construction industry, various risks can threaten the continuity of projects, ranging from damage due to natural disasters, work accidents, to equipment installation failures. To ensure the project can run smoothly without experiencing major losses, insurance plays an important role. The two types of insurance most commonly used in construction projects are Construction All Risk (CAR) and Erection All Risk (EAR). Both have different but complementary functions in providing protection against various risks faced by contractors and project owners.
- Construction All Risk (CAR)
Understanding CAR Insurance
Construction All Risk (CAR) Insurance is a type of insurance designed to provide comprehensive protection for civil construction projects, such as buildings, bridges, roads, dams and other infrastructure. This insurance covers risks that can cause physical damage during the construction period, either due to external factors or human error.
By having a CAR policy, contractors and project owners can avoid financial risks due to unexpected incidents. This policy not only protects the structure of the building under construction, but also covers equipment, materials and legal liability to third parties.
CAR Insurance Policy Coverage
CAR policies typically cover the following risks:
- Damage resulting from natural disasters such as earthquakes, floods, hurricanes and landslides which can damage project structures and hinder work completion.
- Fires, explosions, or theft of project materials, which often occur on construction sites and can cause cost overruns.
- Human errors and accidents on construction sites, including workers falling from heights or technical errors that damage building structures.
- Disruption due to third party negligence, such as a vehicle crashing into a building under construction.
Case Study of the Use of CAR Insurance in Infrastructure Projects
For example, a multi-storey building construction project in Jakarta experienced a fire on one of the floors due to an electrical short circuit. Thanks to Construction All Risk Insurance protection, contractors do not need to cover all repair costs themselves because insurance claims cover most of the damage that occurs. Without this policy, the project could experience significant delays and suffer major losses.
- Erection All Risk (EAR)
Understanding EAR Insurance
Erection All Risk (EAR) Insurance is a type of insurance specifically designed for projects involving the installation of heavy equipment and machinery. These policies are especially important for industrial projects such as power plants, oil refineries, factories, and manufacturing facilities, where the installation of mechanical and electrical equipment is a major part of the construction.
EAR differs from CAR in that it focuses more on risks associated with the installation of equipment, electrical components, and machinery, including risks that arise during testing and commissioning before full operation.
EAR Insurance Policy Coverage
EAR policies cover a variety of risks associated with the installation of industrial equipment and machinery, including:
- Risks during installation of turbines, generators and electrical systems, where small errors in assembly can cause major damage.
- Mechanical failure during test installation, which can cause operational delays and additional repair costs.
- Damage resulting from improper transportation or installation, for example heavy equipment falling during installation or components damaged during shipping.
- Risk of fire, explosion or damage due to external factors affecting the equipment during installation.
Examples of Projects that Require EAR Insurance
One example of a project that really requires Erection All Risk Insurance is the installation of a gas turbine at a gas and steam power plant (PLTGU). During the installation process, the turbine, which is very sensitive to vibration and high temperatures, experienced mechanical failure before being successfully operated. Without EAR insurance, the contractor would have to cover the enormous repair costs themselves.
Another example is in the construction of oil refineries, where pipes and electrical systems must be installed with high precision. Errors in installation can cause gas leaks or even explosions, potentially delaying the project for months.
-
Third-Party Liability Insurance (Third Party Liability Insurance)
In construction projects, not only contractors and project owners are at risk of experiencing losses, but also the community and other parties around the project site. Construction activities often cause disruption or even damage to other people’s property, as well as potential injury to workers or the surrounding community. If an incident involving a third party occurs, the contractor or project owner could face lawsuits and huge compensation claims.
To overcome this risk, Third-Party Liability Insurance is very important protection. This insurance provides coverage against claims submitted by third parties due to the negative impacts of construction projects.
- Pengertian Third-Party Liability Insurance
Third-Party Liability Insurance is a type of insurance that provides protection against lawsuits or compensation claims submitted by third parties due to construction activities. The third parties in question can be individuals, property owners, businesses, or communities who experience losses due to ongoing projects.
In many construction projects, the risk of disturbance to the surrounding environment cannot be avoided. For example, a road construction project can cause vibrations that damage nearby buildings, or the construction of a tall building can result in falling materials that injure pedestrians. In situations like these, the project owner or contractor can be held legally liable, and Third-Party Liability Insurance helps protect them from the financial burden of such claims.
- Third-Party Liability Insurance Policy Coverage
The Third-Party Liability Insurance policy covers various types of risks that construction projects can pose to third parties, including:
Damage to property around the project
Activities such as drilling, pile driving, or moving materials can cause vibrations or stresses that damage buildings near the project. If damage occurs, the affected property owner can submit a claim for compensation to the contractor or project owner.
Injuries or accidents experienced by people around the project
Pedestrians or vehicle drivers may suffer injuries due to accidents that occur in the project area, for example due to materials falling from a height or diversions on roads that are not properly marked. This insurance will cover medical costs or compensation for victims.
Claims from property owners or businesses impacted by construction
Construction projects that cause disruption to road access or excessive noise can harm business owners around the project, for example shops or restaurants who lose customers because access is blocked. If a business owner files a claim due to a decrease in income, this insurance can cover the necessary compensation.
Examples of Third-Party Liability Insurance Use Cases:
Several real-life cases show how important third party liability insurance is in construction projects.
The crane fell and damaged nearby buildings
In a high-rise building project, the crane used experienced a mechanical failure and fell onto the building next to it. The damage caused was quite severe and the building owner filed a compensation claim against the project contractor. If the contractor does not have Third-Party Liability Insurance, they will have to cover all repair costs themselves, which can reach billions of rupiah.
Claims from shop owners due to decreased sales
A road construction project in a commercial area caused access to nearby shops and restaurants to be disrupted for several months. As a result, the shop owner experienced a decline in sales and filed a claim with the project developer for compensation for losses. With third party liability insurance, these compensation costs can be borne by the insurance company, so that the contractor or project owner does not need to bear them directly.
Benefits for Contractors and Project Owners
Using Third-Party Liability Insurance provides various benefits for contractors and project owners, including:
Avoid huge legal fees and compensation
If an incident occurs that results in a lawsuit from a third party, attorney fees, dispute resolution, and compensation can be very high. With this insurance, all costs can be covered by the insurance provider, so that contractors and project owners do not need to spend large amounts of money which could disrupt project finances.
Maintain good relations with the community around the project
Construction projects that impact local communities often create tensions between contractors and local residents. With this insurance, every valid claim can be resolved quickly, so that relations with the community remain harmonious and the project can run without interruption.
Increase credibility in the eyes of project owners and investors
Contractors who have a Third-Party Liability Insurance policy are considered more professional and responsible in managing risks. This increases the confidence of project owners and investors, and can be an added value when participating in tenders for new projects.
In the construction industry, errors in project design, planning, or supervision can have a major impact on the cost, schedule, and quality of construction. These errors can result in lawsuits from the project owner or other affected parties. To protect professionals such as engineers, architects and technical consultants from these risks, Professional Indemnity Insurance (PII) is a very important solution.
- Understanding Professional Indemnity Insurance
Professional Indemnity Insurance (PII) is a type of insurance that provides protection against claims arising from errors in project design, planning or supervision. This policy is especially important for professionals involved in the construction process, such as architects, civil engineers, engineering consultants, and project managers.
In construction projects, inaccurate calculations or inappropriate specifications can create major risks, such as structural failure, unexpected additional costs, or project delays that are detrimental to the project owner. If an error occurs that results in a claim from the client, PII will cover the legal costs, compensation and damages that may have to be paid.
- Professional Indemnity Insurance Policy Coverage
The Professional Indemnity Insurance policy provides protection against various risks related to professional errors in construction projects, including:
Errors in structural calculations that cause buildings to crack or collapse
If a civil engineer makes a mistake in calculating the structural loads of a building, this can cause structural failure that endangers public safety. In this case, the engineer could be sued by the project owner or other affected parties.
Failure in planning that results in additional costs or project delays
Insufficient planning can cause projects to experience cost overruns or even be delayed for months. If the project owner experiences losses due to this, they can file a claim against the consultant or project planner.
Lawsuit from client due to design discrepancy with project specifications
If the architectural design created by an architect does not comply with the specifications agreed in the contract, the client can demand compensation for the additional costs they have to incur to make improvements or revisions to the design.
By having Professional Indemnity Insurance, professionals involved in construction projects can work with more peace of mind, because they have protection against financial risks that could arise due to lawsuits or claims from third parties.
- The Importance of Professional Indemnity Insurance for Engineering Consultants and Architects
For engineers, architects and project consultants, having Professional Indemnity Insurance is a smart step to protect themselves from legal and financial risks due to professional errors. Some of the main benefits of this policy are:
- Protection against lawsuits
If errors occur in the design or planning of the project, the relevant professionals can be sued legally by the project owner. PII will cover the attorney’s fees and compensation that must be paid.
- Avoid financial risks due to professional errors
Mistakes on a construction project can have a major financial impact on a professional or consulting company. Without insurance, they have to bear the costs of compensation themselves, which can reach billions of rupiah.
Case Study: Project Failure Due to Incorrect Design
For example, in a multi-storey building project, an engineer made a mistake in calculating the structural loads which resulted in the top floor experiencing serious cracks after several months of use. The project owner finally demanded compensation for the repair costs they had to incur. If the engineer has Professional Indemnity Insurance, claims and litigation costs may be covered by the insurance company.
In construction projects, the risk of contractor failure in completing work according to the contract always exists. Various factors, such as financial problems, management errors, or delays in material procurement, can cause projects to stall or not be completed according to agreed standards. To reduce this risk, Performance Bonds and Surety Bonds are very important solutions in ensuring project continuity and protecting the project owner from the possibility of contractor default.
- Understanding Performance Bonds and Surety Bonds
Performance Bond
Performance Bond is a guarantee given by the contractor to the project owner as a form of assurance that the work will be completed in accordance with the signed contract. If the contractor fails to fulfill its obligations, the project owner can claim this guarantee to obtain financial compensation or to finance the completion of the project by another party.
Surety Bond
Surety Bond is a form of guarantee provided by a surety company to protect the project owner from the risk of contractor failure. If the contractor cannot fulfill the contract, the guarantee company will provide compensation or appoint another contractor to complete the project. Surety Bonds are often used in government-funded projects or large-scale projects that require additional guarantees against the risk of default or default.
- Performance Bond and Surety Bond Policy Coverage
Both Performance Bonds and Surety Bonds offer extensive protection for project owners in the face of possible contractor failure. Some of the main coverages of this policy include:
- Reimbursement of costs if the contractor fails to complete the project
- If the contractor goes bankrupt or fails to complete the project according to the contract, the project owner can file a claim against the Performance Bond to obtain additional funds to complete the remaining work.
Guarantee of project completion with the quality specified in the contract
Performance Bond ensures that the project is completed according to the quality standards agreed in the contract. If there is a discrepancy in the quality of work, the project owner can claim this guarantee to correct the problem that occurred.
Protection for project owners from the risk of contractor default
If the contractor leaves the project without completing the work or fails to fulfill its obligations in terms of time and quality, the Surety Bond will provide protection by providing compensation or providing a replacement contractor to complete the project.
- Benefits for Project Owners and Contractors
Both Performance Bonds and Surety Bonds provide significant benefits for both parties, namely the project owner and contractor.
Benefits for Project Owners:
- Provides a sense of security in selecting a contractor
- The project owner does not need to worry about the risk of the contractor failing to complete the project because there is a financial guarantee that can be used for work completion.
- Avoid financial risks due to contractor failure
- If the contractor experiences financial difficulties or goes bankrupt, the project owner still has the funds to complete the work without having to bear the full loss.
- Maintain project sustainability
With a guarantee from the guarantor company, the project can continue even if the main contractor fails to fulfill its obligations.
Benefits for Contractors:
- Increase credibility in project tenders
Contractors who have a Performance Bond or Surety Bond will be more trusted by the project owner, especially in large-scale projects. This opens up greater opportunities for them to win tenders for government and private projects.
- Increase the confidence of investors and project owners
Investors and project owners are more likely to choose contractors who have a guarantee, because this shows that the contractor has the financial capacity and professionalism to complete the project.
- Protecting the contractor’s reputation in the construction industry
By having this guarantee, contractors can avoid conflicts or lawsuits due to delays or non-conformities in the project, so that their reputation is maintained.
- Examples of projects that failed due to the absence of a performance bond
In some cases, construction projects experience total failure due to the absence of a Performance Bond. One real example is an infrastructure development project that experienced delays due to the contractor experiencing financial problems. Without this guarantee, the project owner has difficulty obtaining additional funds to find another contractor who can complete the work.
In countries that have strict regulations regarding project guarantees, such as the United States and the European Union, contractors are required to have a Performance Bond in government projects to ensure that construction goes according to plan. Meanwhile, in Indonesia, large projects such as the construction of toll roads, airports or energy infrastructure usually require contractors to have this guarantee to avoid project failure which could harm the state and society.
The Important Role of Insurance Brokers in Construction Insurance
In construction projects, choosing the right project insurance is not easy. Contractors and project owners face various risks, ranging from physical damage, project delays, work accidents, to claims from third parties. Therefore, working with an insurance broker is a strategic step to get optimal protection.
Insurance brokers have a major role in analyzing project risks, recommending appropriate types of construction insurance, and helping contractors and project owners get the best policies with comprehensive coverage. Policies that are often needed in construction include Construction All Risk (CAR), Erection All Risk (EAR), Third-Party Liability Insurance, Professional Indemnity Insurance, as well as Performance Bonds and Surety Bonds.
Apart from that, insurance brokers also have access to various insurance companies, so they can help in negotiating the best premiums and ensure claims are processed quickly and efficiently. In many cases, brokers act as advisors who assist project owners in understanding policy details and ensuring regulatory compliance.
By working with L&G Insurance Brokers, contractors and project owners can obtain the right construction insurance coverage, reduce financial risk, and ensure the project runs without a hitch. Contact L&G Insurance Brokers now for a free consultation and the best project insurance solutions!
Conclusions and Recommendations
In the construction industry, risks cannot be avoided, but can be managed well through proper construction insurance. Various types of insurance such as Construction All Risk (CAR), Erection All Risk (EAR), Third-Party Liability Insurance, Professional Indemnity Insurance, as well as Performance Bonds and Surety Bonds have a crucial role in protecting projects from losses due to accidents, damage, third party claims and contractor failure.
For contractors and project owners, having appropriate insurance protection is not only to avoid financial losses, but also to maintain project sustainability and increase credibility in the eyes of investors and employers. Therefore, it is very important to ensure that the project has adequate insurance coverage from the start.
In choosing the right policy, L&G Insurance Broker is here as a trusted partner who will help contractors and project owners in analyzing risks, choosing the best coverage, and getting competitive premiums. With extensive experience in construction insurance, L&G Insurance Broker is ready to help you get optimal protection solutions that suit your project needs.
Don’t let your project face risks without protection! Contact L&G Insurance Brokers now for a free consultation and get the best insurance solution for your construction project! 🚀
Looking for insurance products? Don’t waste your time and contact us now
HOTLINE L&G 24 JAM: 0811-8507-773 (CALL – WHATSAPP – SMS)
Website: lngrisk.co.id
Email: oktoyar.meli@lngrisk.co.id
—
